Located a short plane or boat ride from St. Maarten and only 16 miles long, Anguilla has long been a favorite of laid-back sophisticates looking for a beach escape. Boasting five-star hotels, private villas, fantastic local restaurants and more than 30 quiet stretches of talcum-powder sand beaches, the Caribbean island offers something for everyone—but choosing the right hotel can be tricky. Indagare breaks down the differences between five of the best options. The Beachfront Classic: Belmond Ca...